Understanding Pricing Models & Fee Structures: Flat-Rate, Interchange-Plus, and Tiered Explained (with examples)
Overview
Processing fees materially impact margins. The main pricing structures are flat-rate (blended), interchange-plus, and tiered (bundled). Understanding how they work will help you choose the lowest-cost option for your business.
The three models, explained
-
Flat-Rate (Blended): A single percentage + per-transaction fee for all transactions (for example, 2.9% + $0.30). Simple and predictable for low-volume merchants. Merchant Maverick
-
Interchange-Plus (Pass-Through): Merchant pays the actual interchange (set by card networks) + a disclosed processor markup. Most transparent and typically cheapest at higher volumes. Merchant Maverick
-
Tiered (Bundled): Transactions are bucketed into “qualified,” “mid-qualified,” and “non-qualified” with different blended rates. Processors often keep some spread; this model can hide costs and is less transparent. Stax Payments
Side-by-side comparison table
Feature | Flat-Rate | Interchange-Plus | Tiered |
---|---|---|---|
Transparency | High (simple) | Very high (line-item) | Low (processor decides tiers) |
Best for | Low/seasonal volume | High/consistent volume | Often small businesses unaware of alternatives |
Typical cost behavior | Can be expensive at scale | Cheapest at scale | Variable; often higher than interchange-plus |
Complexity | Low | Higher (needs statement parsing) | Low |
Worked example — why interchange-plus can beat flat-rate at scale
Assume 1,000 transactions at an average sale of $20:
Step 1 — total sales: 1,000 × $20 = $20,000.
Flat-rate example: 2.9% + $0.30
- Percentage fee: 0.029 × $20,000 = $580.00.
- Per-transaction fee: $0.30 × 1,000 = $300.00.
- Total flat fees = $580.00 + $300.00 = $880.00.
- Effective flat rate = $880 / $20,000 = 0.044 = 4.4%.
Interchange-plus example (sample numbers): assume average interchange of 1.70% + $0.10, processor markup 0.25% + $0.05.
- Interchange percent: 0.017 × $20,000 = $340.00.
- Interchange fixed: $0.10 × 1,000 = $100.00.
- Processor percent markup: 0.0025 × $20,000 = $50.00.
- Processor fixed markup: $0.05 × 1,000 = $50.00.
- Total interchange-plus fees = $340 + $100 + $50 + $50 = $540.00.
- Effective interchange-plus rate = $540 / $20,000 = 0.027 = 2.7%.
This example shows interchange-plus can produce significantly lower costs for higher volumes, which is consistent with industry analysis. Exact savings depend on card mix, MCC, and transaction types. Merchant Maverick+1
Common hidden fees to watch for
-
Monthly gateway fees, PCI compliance service fees, statement fees, chargeback fees, early termination charges, and equipment rental. Transparency varies by provider—pass-through pricing shows line items, while flat/tiered often bury extras. Industry guides consistently recommend asking for a sample statement to audit fees. Fidelity Bank+1
How to choose for your business
- Estimate monthly volume and average ticket.
- Ask providers for an itemized statement with interchange line items.
- Request a sample comparison using your real volumes and card mix (many independent marketplaces help with this).
- If you’re small/seasonal, flat-rate’s simplicity may be best. If you’re growing, interchange-plus usually wins long-term. NerdWallet+1
Where Bay State helps
We audit sample statements and run a side-by-side cost model using your real transaction data to recommend the right pricing structure. For an in-depth guide on selecting the best processor for small business, see: The Best Credit Card Processing Company for Small Businesses.
Small Business
Education & Inspiration
How Restaurants Can Save Big with Smarter POS Systems and Dual Pricing
In today’s competitive restaurant landscape, every dollar counts. Rising...
Why Unified Ordering & Delivery Integration Is a Game Changer for Restaurant POS Systems
As diners increasingly expect seamless online ordering, delivery, and...
Merchant Spotlight: New England House of Pizza – Hyannis, MA
New England House of Pizza – Hyannis, MA For over 40 years, New England...

Speak with one of our LOCAL consultants
Set up a time to speak and meet with one of our local Certified Payment Professionals for a complimentary consultation.